movi47

Refined recommendations

Movies like My Secret Santa (2025) but scarier

movies like My Secret Santa - scarier - more horror, more dread. Hand-filtered from the broader recommendation pool.

← All movies like My Secret SantaMy Secret Santa hub
Ready or Not 2: Here I Come - like My Secret Santa but scarier
#1
6.5

Ready or Not 2: Here I Come

2026

Dracula - like My Secret Santa but scarier
#2
6.2

Dracula

2026

Guardian - like My Secret Santa but scarier
#3
4.0

Guardian

2024

DD Returns - like My Secret Santa but scarier
#4
6.1

DD Returns

2023

Vaalvi - like My Secret Santa but scarier
#5
8.3

Vaalvi

2023

Tu Yaa Main - like My Secret Santa but scarier
6.7

Tu Yaa Main

2026

Curated by Movi47 Editorial Team