movi47

Refined recommendations

Movies like Christmas Pen Pals (2018) but scarier

movies like Christmas Pen Pals - scarier - more horror, more dread. Hand-filtered from the broader recommendation pool.

← All movies like Christmas Pen PalsChristmas Pen Pals hub
Bypass Road - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
#1
5.4

Bypass Road

2019

Bulbbul - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
#2
6.6

Bulbbul

2020

Stalk - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
#3
6.8

Stalk

2019

Trapped - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
#4
7.5

Trapped

2017

ExPatriot - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
#5
4.6

ExPatriot

2017

Sightless - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
6.2

Sightless

2020

Ravening - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
7.7

Ravening

2019

The Elevator - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
4.8

The Elevator

2019

The Immortal - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
6.8

The Immortal

2019

Stolen by Their Father - like Christmas Pen Pals but scarier
6.4

Stolen by Their Father

2022

Curated by Movi47 Editorial Team