Refined recommendations
Movies like Mystery on Mistletoe Lane (2023) but scarier
movies like Mystery on Mistletoe Lane - scarier - more horror, more dread. Hand-filtered from the broader recommendation pool.
#1
5.8
Exterritorial
2025
#2
7.4
Bhoothakaalam
2022
#3
6.6
Deja Vu
2022
#4
5.2
Dark Nuns
2025
#5
6.4
Luckiest Girl Alive
2022
![Kishkindha Kaandam [Malayalam] - like Mystery on Mistletoe Lane but scarier](https://pbcdnw.aoneroom.com/image/2024/11/21/c3e41886798c6176ee875b0ba4fbe749.jpg)
8.0
Kishkindha Kaandam [Malayalam]
2024
5.4
Never Let Go
2024
7.2
Climax
2021
3.8
Find Her
2022
4.9
Beaten to Death
2024
5.4
The Gatekeeper
2024
5.4
Stephen
2025
5.2
A Strange House
2024
6.5
Lift
2021
5.2
Streaming
2025
2.5
Red Light Green Light
2023
6.0
Infinity Pool
2023
6.0
Nightsiren
2022
Curated by Movi47 Editorial Team