Refined recommendations
Shows like Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025) but scarier
shows like Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - scarier - more horror, more dread. Hand-filtered from the broader recommendation pool.
#1
5.2
Dark Nuns
2025
#2
5.2
Streaming
2025
#3
5.8
Exterritorial
2025
![Kishkindha Kaandam [Malayalam] - like Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries but scarier](https://pbcdnw.aoneroom.com/image/2024/11/21/c3e41886798c6176ee875b0ba4fbe749.jpg)
#4
8.0
Kishkindha Kaandam [Malayalam]
2024
#5
5.6
An Honest Life
2025
5.1
Fear Street: Prom Queen
2025
5.8
Murder Mubarak
2024
5.4
Never Let Go
2024
5.3
Neeyat
2023
4.9
Beaten to Death
2024
5.2
A Strange House
2024
5.4
Stephen
2025
5.4
The Gatekeeper
2024
6.0
Infinity Pool
2023
2.5
Red Light Green Light
2023
6.8
Tantiram
2023
5.1
The Deliverance
2024
4.8
Untitled
3.8
Junkyard Dog
2010
6.5
LaRoy, Texas
2024
Curated by Movi47 Editorial Team